Trump publicly supported release of 28 pages on Saudi links to 9/11, but advisors shared inside info on killing of GOP platform plank
Paul Manafort gave news of GOP convention maneuvering to Tom Barrack, who informed UAE’s ambassador
Barrack urged Trump to refrain from making an issue of millions in Saudi money flowing to the Clinton Foundation
By Brian P. McGlinchey
According to leaked emails obtained by Middle East Eye, an unnamed Republican Party figure orchestrated the defeat of a proposed 2016 GOP plank calling for the declassification of 28 pages on Saudi government links to the 9/11 plotters.
That individual then notified Trump presidential campaign manager Paul Manafort of the plank’s defeat and claimed credit for providing instructions to “our political team” to kill it. Continue reading →
A former advisor to vice president Dick Cheney spearheaded the successful drive to kill a Republican Party platform plank that urged the release of 28 pages said to link Saudi Arabia to the 9/11 hijackers.
Steve Yates, who was a deputy national security advisor to Cheney for five years and is now chair of the Idaho Republican Party, offered the amendment that struck the plank. Yates is chair of the platform committee’s national security subcommittee, which narrowly approved the plank on Monday.
The Bush-Cheney administration insisted on classifying the 28 pages, which comprise the final chapter of the report of a 2002 joint congressional intelligence inquiry into 9/11.
In speaking in opposition to the plank, Yates said the idea of releasing the 28 pages “raises the specter that our intelligence gathering may be compromised…and pose a danger to our own national security.”
Yates’ national security claim is strikingly inconsistent with the opinions of other Republicans who have actually read the 28 pages:
John Lehman, 9/11 Commission member and former Secretary of the Navy under President Reagan: “We all have dealt for our careers in highly classified and compartmentalized in every aspect of security. We know when something shouldn’t be declassified….those 28 pages in no way fall into that category.
Rep. Walter Jones: “There’s nothing in it about national security. It’s about the Bush administration and its relationship with the Saudis.”
Sen. Richard Shelby, former chair of the Senate intelligence committee: “I went back and read those pages thoroughly. My judgment is that 95 percent of that information could be declassified.”
Parroting speaking points from CIA Director John Brennan, Yates also claimed that the 28 pages “mainly consists of rumors from third parties that is totally uncorroborated. It is unfair to the individuals involved to allow the speculation to be treated as fact simply because it’s in a secret government report.”
The notion that the 28 pages contain unreliable information has been countered by former senator Bob Graham, who chaired the Senate intelligence committee and co-chaired the inquiry that produced the 28 pages. “There’s been no questions raised about the professionalism and quality of the other 820 pages of that report and this chapter followed the same standards that they did,” said Graham on Meet The Press.
As for the idea that it would be “unfair to the individuals involved” to release the report, classification expert Steven Aftergood, who directs the Federation of American Scientists’ Project on Government Secrecy, told 28Pages.orgearlier this year that “the 28 pages could be entirely false, malicious and nonsensical. That is not a basis for classification and that should not be an impediment to their declassification.”
Should 9/11 Justice Should Be a Private Matter?
Yates concluded with a suggestion that seemed to imply that accountability for an alleged Saudi role should be handled behind closed doors, president to king: “If Saudi officials were complicit in 9/11, that is a matter for both governments to resolve at the highest levels.”
Two other delegates spoke out against the plank in Tuesday’s debate: New York’s Thomas Dadey, who chairs the Onandaga County (Syracuse) GOP and Vermont’s Darcie Johnston.
Given New York’s position in the attacks, Dadey’s opposition no doubt stings for the many 9/11 family members who also call the Empire State home.
Likewise, Johnston’s opposition will strike many supporters of Donald Trump as something of a betrayal: Johnston is a Trump organizer, and her opposition to the plank was contrary to her candidate’s stance on the issue. Trump has indicated he would declassify the 28 pages and has said the classified material implicates Saudi Arabia in the 9/11 attacks.
UPDATE: The 28 pages plank was voted down on Tuesday morning by the full platform committee.
The national security subcommittee of the GOP platform committee today approved a plank that calls for the declassification of 28 pages that are said to link the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to the 9/11 hijackers.
“The public has a right to know,” said Brakey this evening after the platform committee adjourned. “It saddens me that, here we are, 15 years later and it sounds like there’s key pieces of information to our understanding of what happened on that day, and the government has been keeping that information from us.”
Planks are official expressions of the party’s opinions on various issues. To be incorporated in the final platform, the 28 pages plank must first be approved on Tuesday by a majority of the full, 112-member platform committee. Then, along with all the other proposed planks, it must be approved by the full body of next week’s GOP convention in Cleveland.
If adopted, the plank would represent an important new endorsement of the release of the 28 pages. Supporters of declassification already include more than 70 Democratic and Republican members of Congress, former members of the 9/11 Commission and the editorial boards of many of the nation’s most prominent newspapers, including The New York Times and USA Today.
The proposed platform of the Democratic Party, which has already been approved for consideration at the national convention, is silent on this issue, but could theoretically be amended to address it. The Republican platform committee proceedings can be viewed live at CSPAN.
Brakey’s 28 pages plank reads:
Delivering Transparency on Foreign Government Ties to 9/11
As the nation continues to confront terrorism at home and abroad, the American people are being denied access to information that can provide vital insight into the funding of Islamic extremism: 28 classified pages from a 2002 joint congressional intelligence inquiry into the September 11 attacks. A former senator who co-chaired the inquiry says the pages “point a very strong finger at Saudi Arabia as being the principal financier” of the 9/11 attacks and that, by shielding the kingdom from consequences for its actions, the redaction has encouraged its continued sponsorship of extremism and paved the way for the rise of ISIS.
President Obama twice promised 9/11 family members he would release the pages, which could be invaluable in their pursuit of justice in the courtroom. However, his administration has refused to declassify them, even in the face of bipartisan support for their release that includes former 9/11 Commission members and 73 current representatives and senators. These pages must be released. As Thomas Jefferson said, “An enlightened citizenry is indispensable for the proper functioning of a republic. Self-government is not possible unless the citizens are educated sufficiently to enable them to exercise oversight.”